Value EngineeringAugust 21, 2026

Bobrick B-69997 vs ASI 74022: $142.34 Per Unit on the Same Fixture

Satin stainless. Hooded. Double roll. Surface mounted. Twelve and a half inches wide. That describes both of these dispensers exactly — and one of them costs 64% less. Here is the value engineering math, and the honest read on when the swap makes sense and when it does not.

The Two Fixtures
Bobrick

B-69997

Surface-mounted tissue dispenser with hoods, satin finish, two rolls

$221.84/ unit
View product
ASI — our pick

74022-HSSM

Toilet tissue holder, double, hooded, satin stainless, surface mounted

$79.50/ unit
View product
Spec For Spec

Where They Actually Differ

Put the two technical data sheets side by side and the fixtures are functionally interchangeable. The meaningful differences come down to three rows: compliance paperwork, lead time, and price.

SpecificationBobrick B-69997ASI 74022-HSSM
Fixture typeSurface-mounted, double rollSurface-mounted, double roll
HoodYes — hood protects paperYes — hooded
FinishSatin stainless steelSatin stainless steel
Overall width12-3/8"12-5/8"
Overall height6-3/16"6-5/16"
Shipping weight3.3 lbs2.9 lbs
Buy America ActNot listedCompliant
Published lead timeShips in 5–7 business days1–2 weeks (made to order)
Our price$221.84$79.50

Dimensions per each manufacturer's published technical data. Pricing is our own catalog pricing at time of publication and is subject to change — request a current quote for project pricing.

The Math

What It Means On Your Schedule

One dispenser per stall is the normal fixture count. Run that against a typical restroom package and the accessory line moves in a way the whole bid notices.

10 fixtures
$1,423.35
saved
Bobrick$2,218.35
ASI$795.00
25 fixtures
$3,558.38
saved
Bobrick$5,545.88
ASI$1,987.50
50 fixtures
$7,116.75
saved
Bobrick$11,091.75
ASI$3,975.00
100 fixtures
$14,233.50
saved
Bobrick$22,183.50
ASI$7,950.00
Our Position

Why We Lead With ASI

The equivalence is real, not marketing

Same mounting method, same roll configuration, same finish family, within a quarter inch on both critical dimensions. There is no functional compromise being papered over — a facility user could not tell you which dispenser is on the wall.

Buy America Act compliance

The ASI 74022 line carries Buy America Act compliance, which we need on federally funded work — municipal buildings, transit facilities, public schools, and anything touching federal dollars. That paperwork is difficult to substitute for after the fact.

One factory for the whole accessory schedule

ASI builds the full washroom line — grab bars, mirrors, dryers, napkin disposals, baby changing stations. Sourcing the whole schedule from one factory means one submittal package, one lead time to track, and one freight consolidation instead of four.

The savings land where budgets get cut

Accessories are usually the last line item priced and the first one squeezed. Freeing up several thousand dollars there is often what lets the partition spec stay where the architect wanted it, instead of downgrading phenolic to laminate to make a number work.

The Other Side

When We Tell You To Keep The Bobrick

We sell both lines, and there are projects where the Bobrick is genuinely the right call. Any distributor who tells you one manufacturer wins every time is selling their inventory position, not solving your problem.

The specification names Bobrick with no "or equal" clause. Fighting a closed spec over an accessory line rarely pays for the delay it causes.
The facility already standardizes on Bobrick. Maintenance teams stock spindles and keys by manufacturer, and a mixed restroom creates a parts problem that outlives the savings.
A full matching Bobrick accessory suite is going in and the architect cares about consistent styling across every fixture in the room.
The schedule is genuinely tight. Our published lead time on the Bobrick is 5–7 business days against 1–2 weeks made-to-order on the ASI — if the job is closing out this week, that difference decides it.
Dallas–Fort Worth

Local Warehousing Changes The Equation

We are headquartered in Garland and warehouse locally in the DFW metroplex, which means a Dallas–Fort Worth job is not waiting on a factory dock for every fixture. Accessories can be staged with your partitions, released in phases as floors come online, and picked up at will-call the same day when a punch-list item shows up late.

That local buffer is the part of the cost story that never shows up on a line item. Freight on a single dispenser is brutal relative to its price; consolidating an entire accessory schedule into one local delivery — or one truck that also carries your partitions — is where the other few hundred dollars quietly hides.

Will-call pickup

Garland warehouse, same-day on stocked items.

Consolidated freight

Accessories ride with your partition delivery.

Staged releases

Phased to your schedule, not the factory’s.

FAQ

Questions We Get Asked

What is the ASI equivalent of the Bobrick B-69997?
The ASI 74022-HSSM. Both are surface-mounted, double-roll toilet tissue dispensers with protective hoods in satin stainless steel, and both measure roughly 12-1/2" wide by 6-1/4" high. The ASI is also offered in bright polished as the 74022-HBSM, matching the Bobrick B-6999.
How much does the swap actually save?
At our published pricing, $142.34 per unit — about 64%. On a 50-fixture project that removes $7,116.75 from the accessory line without changing the finish, the mounting method, or the roll capacity of the specified fixture.
Is the ASI 74022 the same quality as the Bobrick B-69997?
Both are commercial-grade stainless fixtures from established Division 10 manufacturers, and both are installed in schools, airports, and stadiums across the country. The ASI carries Buy America Act compliance, which matters on federally funded work. Bobrick builds an excellent dispenser — our preference for the ASI on cost-driven projects is about price and sourcing, not a defect in the Bobrick.
When should I still specify the Bobrick?
Keep the Bobrick when you are working to a closed specification that names it without an "or equal" clause, when the facility already standardizes on Bobrick for parts and maintenance, or when you are installing a full matching Bobrick accessory suite and cross-fixture visual consistency matters to the architect.
Will a substitution get rejected in submittals?
Usually not, when the spec includes an "or equal" provision and the substitution is submitted with the manufacturer technical data sheet showing dimensional and functional equivalence. We prepare that submittal package for you at no charge, including the ASI tech sheet and a side-by-side spec comparison for the architect.
Do you stock restroom accessories in Dallas–Fort Worth?
Yes. We are headquartered in Garland, Texas and warehouse locally in the DFW metroplex. That lets us offer will-call pickup, consolidated deliveries, and staged releases timed to your construction schedule instead of shipping every fixture individually from a factory dock.

Send Us Your Fixture Schedule

We will price it both ways — as specified and value engineered — and hand you the side-by-side plus the substitution submittal package. No charge, no obligation, and we will tell you plainly when the swap is not worth making.

Bobrick B-69997 vs ASI 74022: A $142-Per-Unit Value Engineering Swap | Partition Pros